Therefore, the danger associated with crack cocaine versus powder cocaine instead relates to the trade of the drug, not the drug itself. To begin, here are two fascinating cases decided by the u. Federal sentencing disparity between crack and powder. Obama signs law to reduce crack powder sentencing disparity. Supreme court examines disparity in crack and powder. This report addresses disparities in cocaine sentencing in states and documents efforts at the federal and state level to correct these injustices. In oklahoma, which maintains a 6to1 quantitybased sentencing disparity, a tenyear mandatory minimum sentence is triggered for five grams of crack cocaine and 28 grams of powder cocaine. Oct 02, 2007 supreme court weighs harsh crack sentences. The sentencing commission has also reported that many of the rationales originally relied upon to produce the disparity between powder and crack cocaine are unsupportable, because.
Because crack and powder cocaine are two forms of the same drug, there should not be any disparity in sentencing between crack and powder cocaine offenses the only truly fair ratio is 1. While a person found with five grams of crack cocaine faced a fiveyear mandatory minimum prison sentence. The debate over crack powder cocaine sentencing disparity is usually all about federal sentencing, but this local article spotlights a statelevel litigation over these issues in ohio. Apr 17, 2020 download page term paper on disparity in sentencing for crack vs. Obama commutes sentences for 8 in crack cocaine cases the. Us sentencing commission urges congress to reduce crack. An examination of substantial assistance departures in federal crack cocaine and powder cocaine cases richard d. Established by the antidrug abuse acts of 1986 and 1988, the 100to1 ratio relates to the amount of crack versus powder cocaine necessary to trigger mandatory minimum prison sentences meaning that possession of five grams of crack cocaine would mandate the same minimum sentence as 500 grams of powder cocaine. It will also develop recommendations for legislation, and we look forward to working closely with. New drug law narrows crack, powder cocaine sentencing gap. The sentencing disparity for dealing crack and powder cocaine was 100 to 1.
The demographic profile of cocaine offenders must be further examined to analyze any disparity in sentencing. Supreme court weighs 100to1 disparity in crackpowder. The court decision monday rejected the bush administration argument that, because congress had written the ratio into federal law, federal judges could not depart from it. President obama signed a new law tuesday that closes a decadesold gap in federal sentencing that led to much stiffer penalties for crack cocaine cases than ones involving powder cocaine.
Moore asked the sentencing judge to depart downward based on the disparity between crack powder cocaine sentencing. Jun 14, 2007 the us supreme court monday agreed to hear the case of a virginia man sentenced under the harsh federal crack cocaine laws. Download page term paper on disparity in sentencing for crack vs. Supreme court will hear arguments tuesday, october 2, 2007, in a crack powder cocaine sentencing disparity case kimbrough v. Here are the sentencing disparities between crack and cocaine. A push to shrink the disparity in punishments got a boost last month when reduced federal sentencing. Regardless of changes in the federal law, a charge of crack or powder cocaine is a very serious charge. Washington president obama, expanding his push to curtail severe penalties in drug cases, on thursday commuted the sentences of eight federal inmates who were convicted of crack cocaine offenses. Whereas, the fiveyear federal mandatory minimum sentencing amount for cocaine base hereinafter crack is five grams and the corresponding amount for cocaine hydrochloride hereinafter powder cocaine is 500 gms. The tide is clearly turning against the failed war on drugs.
Supreme court weighs harsh crack sentences cbs news. Crack cocaine sentencing laws in the adaa also included a fiveyear mandatory. Race and class penalties in crack cocaine sentencing. A 1994 justice department survey of felony cases in the countrys 75. Critics of the sentencing disparities between crack and powder have. The ussc has taken the lead on eliminating the crackpowder sentencing disparity by amending the federal sentencing guidelines to lessen the punishment range for crack cocaine cases by approximately one to two years. An examination of substantial assistance departures in federal crackcocaine and powdercocaine cases richard d. Since then the federal bureau of prisons began to have budget and overcrowding problems. Sentencing commission regarding the powder crack cocaine sentencing disparity and reconsider proposals to amend the law. Under the old sentencing guidelines, the penalty for possessing a gram of crack cocaine was the same as that for possessing 100 grams or about 312 ounces of powder cocaine, with a corresponding. Criminal division aag breuer testimony re restoring fairness. Though his case is an illustration of the disparitys pernicious effects, the.
Crack and cocaine powder sentencing disparities essay example. Feb 19, 2015 in light of the current sentencing disparity18. The commission also urged congress to reform federal mandatory minimum sentences to reduce the statutory disparity. Now, the ten year sentence is triggered by 280 grams of crack instead of 50. Obama commutes sentences for 8 in crack cocaine cases. In arizona, which has a 12to1 disparity, nine grams of powder cocaine or less than a gram.
Assistant majority leader dick durbin dil introduced the fair sentencing act of 2009, a narrowlytailored bill that would eliminate the sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine and increase penalties for the worst offenders. Much of the discrepancy at the federal level is the result of differences in the federal sentencing of drug offenses involving crack and powder cocaine. Aug 04, 2010 fox news segment on president obama signing new legislation to reduce the crack powder sentencing disparity. An examination of substantial assistance departures in federal crack. In 2010, congress passed the fair sentencing act fsa, which reduced the sentencing disparity between offenses for crack and powder cocaine from 100. In 1986, during the reagan administrations antidrug initiative, congress enacted a federal sentencing policy of punishing crimes involving crack cocaine at a 100to1 ratio compared to crimes involving powder cocaine. As introduced, the fair sentencing acts provisions would have completely eliminated the sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine and its impact in reducing racial disparity and growing federal incarceration rates would have been more dramatic. Trafficking in 5 grams of crack cocaine carries a mandatory fiveyear prison sentence, but it takes 500 grams of cocaine powder. Apr 30, 2009 the 1986 and 1988 antidrug abuse acts created a disparity in sentencing between two forms of cocaine, crack cocaine and powder, at the federal level even though scientific evidence, including a. Crackpowder disparity testimony of wade henderson the. Some 2020 democratic candidate argue that the sentencing disparity between crack cocaine and powder cocaine, which now sits at 18to1, should be. House republicans and democrats are in agreement that u.
Circuit court of appeals in richmond said judges are not free to impose sentences shorter than the guidelines based on a disagreement with the sentencing disparity for crack and. Supreme court will hear arguments tuesday, october 2, 2007, in a crackpowder cocaine sentencing disparity case kimbrough v. The first lash against the eighth circuit came in the case of james eric moore who was convicted of one count of possessing crack cocaine. Under the current law, crack users possessing only 5 grams of the drug are charged with a felony to get the same charge, powder cocaine users have to be caught with 500 grams. The quantity distinction has also resulted in a massive sentencing disparity by race, with african americans receiving longer sentences than the mostly white and. Oct 02, 2007 court mulls crackcocaine sentencing disparity the supreme court hears arguments in two drugcrime cases tuesday. Aug 03, 2010 data show racial disparity in crack sentencing. Apr 29, 2009 the sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine but also fully accounts for violence, chronic offenders, weapon possession and other aggravating factors associated in individual cases with both crack and powder cocaine trafficking.
Crack and cocaine powder sentencing disparities essay sample. The debate over the penalties for possessing crack cocaine versus those for the powder version of the drug is being. To do this, we go back eight years before the acts effective date to the fair sentencing act. Congress passes law to reduce crackpowder cocaine sentencing.
That year, national news outlets began reporting inflammatory anecdotes supposedly revealing a crack epidemic. This federal law reduces the disparity between criminal sentences for crack and powder cocaine from 100to1 to 18to1 and eliminates the mandatory minimum fiveyear sentence for simple possession of crack cocaine. Data show racial disparity in crack sentencing us news. Aug 03, 2010 today president obama signed the fair sentencing act of 2010 into law.
Thousands are stuck in prison just because of the date they were sentenced. The law includes what critics have called a 100to1 disparity. Criminal division aag breuer testimony re restoring. The figures for the 6,020 powder cocaine cases are far less skewed. After president obama signed off on new legislation to reduce the sentencing disparity between people caught with crack cocaine and those caught with powder cocaine, the minnesota democrat spoke to huffpost about what it all means. Current federal penalties for selling 5 grams of crack cocaine can warrant the same prison sentence as dealing 500 grams of the powdered variety. One is a further test of the new use of the old sentencing. Federal crack cocaine sentencing the sentencing project. Court mulls crack cocaine sentencing disparity the supreme court hears arguments in two drugcrime cases tuesday. One is a further test of the new use of the old sentencing rules, which the court.
Defendant gall joined an ongoing ecstasy drug ring while in college. Race and class penalties in crack cocaine sentencing by michael coyle overview after a decade of contentious debate regarding the federal sentencing disparities between crack cocaine and powder cocaine, a number of significant initiatives to reform current policy. Regardless of changes in the federal law, a charge of crack or powder. The american civil liberties union filed a friendofthecourt brief in the case. Crack cocaine and powder cocaine are the same drug, simply sold in different forms. A comprehensive examination of the 100to1 crack versus powder cocaine sentencing disparity under which distribution of just 5 grams of crack carries a minimum 5year federal prisonsentence, while distribution of 500 grams of powder cocaine carries the same 5year mandatory minimum sentence.
Crack and cocaine powder sentencing disparities essay. One would think, based on the sentencing laws, that crack cocaine is a very different drug than powder cocaineand much. Apr 19, 2012 five myths of the racist criminal justice system. Fair sentencing act american civil liberties union. At issue is whether a federal judge has the discretion to impose a more lenient sentence on sellers of crack cocaine based on a finding that the 100. The ussc subsequently recommended rectifying the unfounded sentencing disparity between the two types. And according to the university of michigan study, at the federal level alone simply eliminating the sentencing disparity would reduce the number of black men in.
For example, the sentencing guidelines prescribe the same sentence for a defendant convicted of dealing 500 grams of powder. Edward douglas is serving a life sentence for selling crack cocaine. In the three decades prior to the passing of the fair sentencing act, those who were arrested for possessing crack cocaine faced much more severe penalties than those in possession of powder cocaine. Under the 2010 law, the amount of crack that triggers the fiveyear minimum is 28 grams of crack or 500 grams of powder, and, for the tenyear minimum, 280 grams of crack and 5,000 of powder. That resulted in a disparity with powder of about 18 to 1. The disparity in punishment has often been challenged as being racially oriented, because africanamerican offenders more often are involved in possessing or distributing crack than they are powder. Mar 12, 2018 having some overview of sentencing procedure and the federal sentencing guidelines, lets now take a look at a few sentencing examples from realworld federal cases. The united states sentencing commission, the bipartisan body that sets guidelines for federal prison sentences, urged congress to eliminate the sentencing disparity more than a decade ago.
The fair sentencing act amends existing laws by increasing the amounts of crack that trigger these penalties, from five grams to 28 grams for fiveyear minimum sentences and from 50 grams to 280 grams for tenyear minimum sentences. Keith ellison spent 16 years as a trial lawyer dealing with hundreds of cases involving cocaine arrests. Cracked justice updated 32411 2 sentencing project. High court eases crack sentence guidelines cbs news. In a pair of cases involving drug crimes, trial court judges handed down sentences that were shorter than those called for in the federal sentencing. Now that disparity is being reduced from 100to1 to 18to1. What is the chemical difference between crack cocaine and powder cocaine.
But in reality, according to experts, crack cocaine and powder cocaine are essentially identical. Sentencing commission found the crack powder disparity inconsistent with the 1986 acts concerns about penalizing serious drug traffickers more severely than streetlevel dealers. Crack cocaine first hit the national radar in 1986 but, contrary to media reports, it was not a new drug. A 2010 federal law rectified some, though not all, of the sentencing disparities. This disparity between crack and powder cocaine was driven by fear. While this is a step in the right direction, a significant. A comprehensive examination of the 100to1 crack versus powder cocaine sentencing disparity under which distribution of just 5 grams of crack carries a.
In 79% of the 1993 crack cases and 71% of the powder cases, the minimum of the guideline range was higher than the applicable statutory mandatory minimum. The amount of powder cocaine necessary to trigger the sentence is still five kilos. On august 3, 2010, president obama signed into law historic legislation that reduces the twodecadesold sentencing disparity between federal crack and powder cocaine offenses. While this is a step in the right direction, a significant disparity remains and the law has not been made retroactive.
Before 1986, federal sentencing laws treated possession of crack and powder cocaine the same. In response, the antidrug abuse act of 1986 included a provision that created the disparity between federal penalties for crack cocaine and powder cocaine. The sentencing disparities between crack and cocaine attn. Today, states maintain sentencing disparities between crack and powder cocaine offenses. President obama signed a new law that will close the longdisputed 100. For example, the possession of 2 ounces of crack cocaine carried a 10 year mandatory minimum jail sentence compared to 179 ounces of powder cocaine for the same penalty. President obama signed the new sentencing law on august 3, 2010. In 2010 congress passed the fair sentencing act, which repealed the mandatory minimum sentence for simple possession and reduced the sentencing disparity from 100. Trafficking in 5 grams of crack cocaine carries a mandatory fiveyear prison sentence, but it. So, the federal law still imposes a different and harsher sentence for crack cocaine possession than it does for powder cocaine possession, but the disparity is not nearly as great as under the 1986 act.
Such a change would permit judges to consider the full range of sentencing criteria in all crack cocaine cases, rather than in just the relatively modest number of cases permissible under the current sentencing structure. The commission stated that the crackpowder sentencing differential fosters disrespect for and lack of confidence in the criminal justice system because of a widelyheld perception that it promotes. An end to crackpowder cocaine sentencing disparity. Dec 10, 2007 high court eases crack sentence guidelines.
1218 1456 1547 1376 1663 175 506 1086 44 886 1530 704 963 785 1576 1219 1601 669 537 802 1259 1338 518 1425 801 293 1202 856 1311 1287 795 492 981 611 512 481